Aspiration: Mecca

Aspiration: Mecca

This is not a trip report.

This is an article about a city of global significance that sees little coverage on travel blogs; a place that is simultaneously mysterious and very popular; one that I would absolutely love to visit, but probably never will.  This is an article about Mecca.

Mecca (Makkah) is a city with over 2,000 years of history.  Situated in the present-day Saudi Arabia, it is Islam’s holiest city where Prophet Muhammad was born and had his first revelation of the Quran.  Millions of Muslim pilgrims travel there annually, in a tradition that has lasted 14 centuries.  As a result, Mecca is reportedly one of the most diverse and cosmopolitan cities in the Muslim world.

mecca_0_1

In the English language, the word “mecca” is synonymous with a place that “many people visit or hope to visit”.  People with absolutely no knowledge of or interest in Islam may find themselves using the name in a sentence like “Madison Square Garden is the mecca of basketball.”

The city of Mecca is serviced by King Abdulaziz International Airport (JED) in Jeddah, 100km northwest of the city.  You can get there on Saudia via New York, Lufthansa via Frankfurt, British Airways via London, Emirates via Dubai, Etihad via Abu Dhabi, etc.  Once there, familiar brands of accommodation including Fairmont, Le Meridien, Hyatt, Hilton, and Marriott exist throughout the city. Options to visit Mecca on points seem abundant.

Resources like MuslimTravelGirl exist to help Muslims understand the logistics around planning pilgrimages to Mecca.  Aside from her, no blogger on BoardingArea has thus far made mention of this city.  I was intrigued by that because, even as a non-believer, I found Mecca to be fascinating for many reasons.

 

TOP TRAVEL DESTINATION IN HUMAN HISTORY

Masjid al-Haram, a.k.a. the Grand Mosque of Mecca, is among the religious wonders in the world.  It is not only the oldest and largest mosque in the world, it is also at the heart of the Islamic pilgrimages known as Hajj (taking place during a very specific five-day window of the year) and Umrah (same trip during any other part of the year).  Each capable Muslim is required to perform the Hajj once in his or her lifetime.  That is, even when you exclude curious travel enthusiasts like me, 1.6 whopping billion people currently alive either have been to Mecca or wish to go there at some point.

mecca_1_0

Masjid al-Haram contains some of Islam’s most important relics: the Kaaba, the mysterious Black Stone, and the well Zamzam (that my favorite restaurant in Singapore is apparently named after).  The original mosque structure was established by Muhammad himself in 7th century A.D..  Subsequently, it has been rebuilt several times to accommodate the ever-increasing number of people coming to it.  Currently occupying 88.2 acres of land with an official capacity of 900,000, it holds more people than the eight largest American football stadiums combined.  During Hajj, they allow up to 4 million people in the mosque at the same time.

mecca_1_1
And I thought my school had a large football stadium…

The annual Hajj in recent years averaged 2-3 million pilgrims.  The 2015 Ramadan reportedly saw over 14 million visitors to Mecca.  Compared to the New Year’s Eve celebration in Times Square, which draws 1 million visitors each year, this is highly impressive.  Considering that these pilgrimages have been taking place since around the 7th century A.D., the Islamic holy city is possibly the most visited destination in human history.

At this point, some of you might say “just because everyone is doing it does not mean you should too.” That’s true, technically.  But try telling that to Yelp or Instagram users – humans are naturally attracted to what the others are doing.  If all your friends posted a selfie in front of the Eiffel Tower, it’s hard to resist booking yourself a flight to Paris.  It fascinates me to no end that countless people have traveled here for the same purpose, while empires around the world rose and fell.  If you are a true travel enthusiast, I bet you’d itch to check it out, as well.

 

CENTER OF SPIRITUAL ENERGY

Kaaba is the black cubical structure in the center of Masjid al-Haram.  Muslims believe that it was originally built by Abraham and has a 4,000-year history.  It was the reason for the gigantic mosque to be built where it was built.  It contains a mosque on the inside, through a 300kg gold door.

mecca_2_0
Even though this black cube looks like a small dot in the middle of the Grand Mosque, it’s as tall as a typical four-story building.

When I first saw the picture of Kaaba as a kid, I was disappointed by its lack of architectural complexity.  As I think about it now, its simple geometric shape actually makes it stand out among the world’s man-made structures.  What other famous building looks like a cube?  Oh yeah, the Fifth Avenue Apple Store, which I was convinced to be a modern copy of the Kaaba…

mecca_2_1
On its opening day 10 years ago, iPilgrims formed a circular line around this Apple Store’s entrance.  It looked awfully similar to a ritual performed during the Hajj.

Anyhow, I digress.  The significance of the Kaaba is that it is considered the “House of God”.  No matter where they are in the world, Muslims face Kaaba’s direction when they pray.  This direction is called Qibla, and a lot of mathematics went into precisely calculating it for all possible prayer locations on Earth.  Guidelines have even been established for Muslim astronauts to determine Qibla in outer space!

Muslims have five daily prayers.  So for each rotation the Earth makes, more than one prayer per living (human) soul is channeled to this very specific location.  That’s an incredible number.  Most other religions don’t have a comparable earthly location (Judaism being an exception).  So, if an alien spaceship approaches Earth and can measure the spiritual signals generated by these prayers, the location of Kaaba must look like the single most important spot on this planet.

If it’s starting to sound hypocritical for a non-believer to discuss spiritual signals, let’s dial back and think about just the physical indicators of Qibla.  Establishments (such as hotels) in many countries have arrows that point in the direction of Mecca, to spare their patrons of needing a compass.  Each time I walked into a hotel room with such an arrow, I’d pause for a second and think about what direction it was, the workers who put it in place, and the guests who have followed it to perform their prayers.  This curiosity accumulated over time, and I became more and more interested in seeing whatever these arrows were pointing to.

mecca_2_2

 

THE MODERN MARVEL

The historic and religious aspects of Mecca are no doubt incredible, but what really caught my attention were the more recent developments in this city.  I love skyscrapers, and the world’s coolest (in my opinion) resides here:

mecca_3_0

Abraj al Bait, a.k.a. Makkah Royal Clock Tower Hotel, is the world’s third tallest building.  In a world where everyone is fighting to be number one, that alone may not sound too impressive.  However, this building is not only tall, it is also ridiculously large.  It’s got far more floor space than any other skyscraper in the world, equivalent to 7.5 Empire State Buildings.

mecca_3_1
Individual diagrams courtesy of SkyscraperPage.com.

The “clock tower” part of it has the four largest clock faces in the world.  Each of them can fill up half of an American football field.  On a clear day, these clocks are supposedly visible from 16 miles away.  Wow… Imagine being able to see anything in Manhattan from Long Island!

mecca_3_4
The length of the minute hand is equivalent to three first downs.

This mega structure looks like a fortress from a fantasy movie, and it stands right next to the Grand Mosque.  Well-to-do pilgrims who can afford to stay at the Fairmont Hotel within the Clock Tower have very convenient access to the holy site.

mecca_3_2
The mosque that can hold 4 million people looks small at the foot of Abraj al Bait.

It’s impressive enough for any city to have a mega structure like Abraj al Bait, but Mecca isn’t stopping there.  To accommodate the ever-increasing number of pilgrims, another gigantic hotel is being built.  When completed, Hotel Abraj Kudai will have 10,000 rooms and five helipads.  In the nearby city of Jeddah, Kingdom Tower is scheduled to claim the title of the world’s tallest building, exceeding Burj Khalifa by a whopping 20% and reaching one kilometer in height.

mecca_3_3
Artist rendering of Kingdom Tower (left) and Hotel Abraj Kudai (right)

It is unfortunate, however, that the construction of these modern structures involved the demolition of some ancient artifacts in Mecca, a move that has sparked much controversy.  Some of my Muslim friends (who because of their religion value these artifacts greatly) have been harshly critical of the Saudi Arabia government for this.

 

JUST A SLIGHT PROBLEM

I started looking into the logistics for my eventual visit, and came across this note: NON-MUSLIMS ARE PROHIBITED FROM ENTERING MECCA.

Hmm.  I had always known that the Grand Mosque, being the holiest site of the Islamic faith, was strictly forbidden from non-Muslims.  I was bummed as a child to learn that I wouldn’t be able to check out the Kaaba (unless my faith drastically changes, of course).  But the entire city of Mecca?  That can’t be right.  How can they possibly enforce that kind of rule on the millions of visitors?  Like, set up a check point on every road leading into the city, stop every car, and examine every soul?

Turns out that’s actually the case… Somebody had already tested this out.

Then, I wondered, how would they know if I were a Muslim?  There are plenty of Muslims in East Asia and I look like them!  It’s not like Donald Trump has already reigned over the world and required every Muslim to register for an ID.  Can I, say, just smile and nod when the Mecca Border Patrol asks me to confirm my faith?  Being agnostic, it wouldn’t be overly insincere of me to claim partial belief in anything… But, once again, Saudi Arabia has proven itself to be several steps ahead of my thinking.  Tourist travel is strictly prohibited, and any visa application requires sponsorship or an official invitation letter.  Forget Mecca.  I won’t even be allowed to enter the country!

In researching how I might cheat my way into seeing the wonders of Mecca, I came across a trip report of a truly hardcore “travel hacker”.  This British guy recently pretended to be Muslim in order to go through Hajj, following the pilgrims every step of the way.  He documented his three-part physical and spiritual journey (part 1, part 2, part 3), a highly recommended read for anyone who shares my curiosity.

 

CONCLUSION

Despite my lack of belief in any particular supreme being, I recognize that some of the most incredible things in human history would not have been accomplished without a religious purpose.  Each time I get the opportunity to witness one of these wonders, I gain a sense of appreciation for the power of faith behind it.  The experience can be a better lesson about a religion than any textbook in the world.  Mecca, at least on paper, seemed to be one of the best travel destinations for understanding a religion.

mecca_4_0
Potala Palace
in Llasa and St. Peter’s Basilica in Vatican City are two such religious establishments that I’ll have to visit one day

I recently read that for non-Muslims, Mecca can be harder to get into than North Korea and Antarctica.  As such, I will have to take it off my travel checklist, for now, and just hope that Saudi Arabia changes its tourism policies within my lifetime.

What do you all think about this?

  • Does anyone else share my enthusiasm, or am I crazy for wanting to visit Mecca?
  • If you are a Muslim, do you agree that non-Muslims should stay out of the holy city?

 

Disclaimer: I deserve credit for only two of the pictures above.  All photos of Mecca are taken from public sources including Wikipedia and news sites.

 

17 Comments

  1. What an absolutely wonderful read. As a Muslim it makes me so happy to read things like this, not because i’m Muslim but more because we can find good in all things no matter how different they are from what you know or believe in, like you have showed in your article today.

    I actually used to live in Saudi (Riyadh) when I was very young. Although i’m 37 now, I remember going for Hajj like it was yesterday. I remember so many fine details it’s almost strange, like my dad picking me up so I could touch the black stone, and the coolness of the marble floor on my feet as we mad the rounds around the Kaaba. Many of my friends who have gone more recently have said it is a truly magical experience. I can fully see what they mean.

    As for not letting non Muslims enter, I don’t agree with it however the reasons that those laws are in place may be well above my knowledge of things. Having said that, I think that letting non Muslims enter would go far and beyond in terms of the world’s understand of who Muslims really are. During the pilgrimage there are truly no boundaries. Everyone is equal in every way. Everyone is dressed the same. All men and women are equal, praying side by side. There are no sects, there is no segregation…black, white, brown, rich, poor, educated, uneducated…everyone is equal in front of God. It is truly a beautiful thing.

    Here’s to more articles like this in the travel blog world….exploring the unexplored!!!

    Reply
    • Faisal – Your words of encouragement mean a lot to me. Travel is an activity that’s supposed to bring people closer to one another. Even in this case where actual visits are unlikely, I’m hoping that by drawing the parallels between the most forbidden place in the Muslim world and what we find cool in the Western world, more of us will appreciate the similarities that we all share.

      However I complain about being unable to enter Mecca, I believe that respecting local laws and customs is an integral part of understanding a culture. Some people openly share what’s sacred to them; others prefer to keep it private. If everyone’s openness were completely the same to begin with, the world would’ve been a less interesting place.

      Reply
  2. Great blog post. I have thought about visiting Saudi Arabia, though not Mecca specifically. But your article and the pics really piqued my interest in that city, so I felt a little twinge of sadness when I read your conclusion that it’s not possible for me either (haha). Oh well, lots of other interesting places to visit. Safe travels.

    Reply
    • I know people who’ve visited Saudi Arabia on business travel, and read that visiting relatives is another acceptable reasons for applying for a visa. Neither applies to me, but if you manage to go I’d love to hear your stories.

      Even outside Mecca, I read that the country has some of the most awesome mosques in the world.

      Reply
  3. Great post !!!! You can consider Makkah to be the cantonment area of Muslims 🙂

    Reply
  4. By the way the restriction for non-Muslims to enter Makkah actually comes from a verse in the Holy Quran, so even Saudi Arabia can not do much about it

    Reply
    • I see. As a non-Muslim I wouldn’t fully understand the rationale, but I respect local laws and customs and am by no means trying to suggest that the rules “should” change.

      Reply
  5. I thought about going to Mecca as well when I was a kid but that would mean I have to change religions, which I’m not willing to do so I know I’ll never visit Mecca; and I’m ok with that.
    If you really really want to visit Mecca, I suggest learning more about Islam and if you believe in a lot of their teachings, then convert and in a few years, you’ll be able to go to Mecca and participate as a pilgrim (not a tourist!) 🙂
    You can go to KSA as a tourist but through an organized tour. A friend did this a few years ago but only went to Jeddah and Riyadh.
    One thing that fascinated me about KSA (moreso than Mecca) is the public executions in public square like Deera (sp?) square in Riyadh. I’m not sure where else in the world a scheduled public execution would take place that can be treated as a spectacle. I’m not saying I want to see it myself but I am fascinated that this still occurs somewhere on earth.

    Reply
    • Haha glad to hear from a like-minded person. I don’t think changing religion can be an active decision, and understanding doesn’t necessitate belief. But if it works for anyone, I would certainly applaud the travel enthusiast hardcore enough to alter his/her own belief just to visit a place!

      Reply
  6. I have wanted to go to Saudi Arabia since I can remember, Mecca specifically. However, I am a Christian woman who travels by myself so it’s something I will simply never be able to do. I actually considered trying to fly Saudi airlines so I could at least pass through the airport.
    Mecca itself has fascinated me for a long time and I would love to see it but the restrictions put on non-Muslims will simply not allow it and I do not see that ever changing.

    Reply
    • We can only hope, right?

      Reply
    • Beth I would say that Jeddah airport is nothing impressive, it is an old building and it can be hard to navigate. Wait until the new Jeddah airport is built and open then it might be more fun to have a stop-over. 🙂

      Reply
  7. What a lovely read! I am well impressed and thanks for the mention.

    I remember 10 or more years ago when I was still a non Muslim watching the Hajj or Ramadan on TV in Greece and thought to myself ” Oh these weird people paying to a stone” Though I was totally smitten by the fact they all prayed together so well and it looked absolutely amazing.

    10+ years and I am a muslim, I never expected to like visiting Makkah, I for sure know I won’t be able to live in the city but the experience of Umrah cannot be described in words. I especially loved the Ramadan Umrah which I did, It was packed but the peace and serenity was overwhelming.

    With regards to papers for enter you need a conversion certificate from a mosque and for women a female guardian (ie husband). As Naif said it is in the Quran that non Muslims cannot enter the city, and even I got an email from Hilton saying this (assuming I wasn’t a Muslim wanted to enter).

    Personally I do believe non Muslims shouldn’t enter and it’s sad because I would love to take my mother there. But firstly it is in the Quran and secondly Makkah is a holy place for pilgrims every ritual has it’s place and the space is very tight. Having tourists even from logistical perspective to wander around would make it harder for everyone. I couldn’t understand this until I went for Umrah and saw the crowds. 🙂

    Reply
    • Wow! Honored to have MuslimTravelGirl dropping by!

      I understand that Hajj / Ramadan can be super crowded, but does Makkah have an off season?

      Reply
      • There is really no off-season, rather slow season. Usually it is quieter after the main holidays. The off season if you can call it this is after Hajj when the visas are not open for anyone other than the GCC countries. Hotels are cheap, less crowd yet only few can go 🙁

        Reply
  8. One of my readers linked to your article in the comment section, and I’m glad they did. What an interesting read! While it’s unfortunate you can’t enter Mecca, you can in fact enter Saudi Arabia as a tourist via Riyadh. The government is really starting to bank on tourism since oil revenue has declined. I haven’t been to Riyadh and obviously it lacks the spiritual significance of Mecca, but it’s an option if you want to see a part of the country.

    Reply
    • Thanks! And that reader was me… will look into the Riyadh option.

      Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. My Umrah Experience: Inside Masjid Al Haram in Mecca - […] gotten some comments recently about why non-Muslims can’t enter Mecca, and comparing that to the recent Muslim immigration ban.…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

BoardingArea